Wall Street Strategies
Hello! Sign in or Register


Question of the Week

Can Europe ever regain its former glory or has the welfare mentality doomed it to serfdom?
Post your answer below.

Morning Commentary

Learning What not to Do from the Europeans

By Charles Payne, CEO & Principal Analyst
5/9/2012 8:17 AM

So the market makes a delayed reaction to European votes and then finds a way to rebound into the close. It was a nice move although the market was still lower; gold is crashing and the ten year yield screams of worry and crisis. The key characteristic of Rally 2012 has been resolve, but the shenanigans in Europe are wearing out investors all over again. Watching it all play out is like watching the last race after a long night at the demolition derby. That last race pits all the losing cars from earlier in the evening in a blind free for all.

You Have to Beat the Germans in Innovation and Discipline

In 9AD the Roman Empire continued to expand and made it through lands controlled by Germanic tribes. It was here that Romans saw its armies broken in the most decisive way to date at the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest. Despite leading a force that consisted of the sixteenth, eighteenth, and nineteenth legions, Publius Quintilius Varus was so humiliated in defeat, he took his own life. The victory is seen in Germany as the birth of German history and the leader of the rag tag confederation of tribes, Arminius, continues to be seen as a hero. By 260 AD Germanic people broke through Roman lines at the Limes and Danube, expediting the eventual fall of the then greatest empire in the history of mankind.

Over -Civilized & Decadent
Vs
Creative & Vital

In Germany they still refer to Welshmen Erbfeind, which loosely translated speaks to the Latin speaking archenemies of Germany. Arminius (also Hermann, his German name) is still used as a rally cry in Germany where they have seen their confrontations with Mediterranean neighbors as over-civilized and decadent while viewing themselves as creative and vital. For the most part the creative and vital Germans have gotten the better of the deal, save for that moment in the sun for napoleon. Interestingly, the battle never stopped and continues to this day. What we are watching in Europe today is the continued failure of the over civilized and decadent, along with the notion that linking arms in a collective makes the overall group stronger.

Both are cautionary tales for American voters looking to buy into the idea that we are all better off linking up and letting the government lead us by the nose. It also proves the cream rises to the top, not as a function of fairness and redistribution, but as a result of determination and work ethic.

Whenever Europe has had the chance to hem in Germany it has worked tirelessly to build giant moats. The Treaty of Versailles went a long way toward neutralizing Germany. While there is no doubt German destruction took a heavy toll on the continent it is said the treaty was an appeal to emotions rather than reason. The terms were so onerous that many, including the British representative, believed the nation would be vulnerable to accepting communism. As it turns out, those fears were valid but it was Socialism or National Socialism, also known as Nazism, that erupted when the Weimer republic sank under the economic strains of the treaty.

Still the treaty was signed on June 28, 1919, at the Paris Peace Conference.

Terms of the treaty include:

* Accepting reasonability for starting war (the Guilt Clause)
* Disarm
* Reduce military by 100,000 men
* No tanks
* No air force
* No submarines
* Six naval ships
* Give up territory
* Alsace-Lorraine-France
* Eupen and Malmedy-Belgium
* Northern Schleswig-Denmark
* West Prussia, Pasen and Upper Silesin-Poland
* Pay Reparations of $31.0 billion or $442 billion in 2010 dollars

The bitterness was obvious and the world was hurting. In addition to the aftermath of war, the Spanish flu killed 25 million. Still the idea was to take away Germany's ability to be competitive. The deal actually created the backdrop for the rise of the most evil person to walk the face of the earth. After Germany lost WWII there was yet another attempt, ostensibly, to curtail its military ambitions and might, to slow down its creativity and vitality. In the aftermath of the post WWII ring fence Germany was nudged into committing to the Euro by France in return for supporting reunification. That was 1989 and on February 7, 1992, the Maastricht Treaty was signed.

The Euro was born and went into effect on January 1, 1999, and a unified Germany was hitting its stride once again. Those workaholic Germans now control the Euro as the largest economy and the one with the only wiggle room to pay its debt-ridden neighbors. Still, even in the face of obvious fiscal decline the over civilized remain defiant and decadent. France is back to its official socialist ways and a communist is starting all kinds of trouble in Greece. Here's the rub for Americans. Combining the economic might and supposedly adding a pinch of economic discipline was supposed to make Europe stronger. In fact, Europe is weaker in part because its welfare mentality was able to thrive.

Policies and aims to compete with Germany not as rivals of quality, but by leveling the playing field, have made the Welschen Erbfeind less competitive. Now here we stand with profligate spenders demanding another bite at the apple, forgiveness of past debts and doubling down on policies that mean economic suicide. I don't believe communist Greeks have the guts to bail on the Euro, but they know how to milk the situation. Yesterday's reversal might signal Wall Street's willingness to call their bluff - for sure; I know the Germans will. If the Greeks and French want to dig deeper into the pockets of Germans, I suspect the spirit of Arminius will spur a counter movement.

History shows that national pride can morph into something more dangerous, but it always aids in the creation of economic prosperity. The gimmicks, the whining, and the selfish demands are a waste of time. The only thing that stops the Germans is military conquest, so maybe the best thing Greece could hold out for is an invasion after they refuse to pay up on past debts and obligations.

Market

Stock are headed for lots of volatility today as investors focus more and more on the euro zone's mounting debt. In particular, Spain is becoming unstable again, as its 10-year yields push through 6 percent on Greek concerns and on word that Bankia is getting a bailout and may be nationalized

We're looking at a rough opening, down in triple digits as the mayhem in Europe continues. Leaders in Greece are now expecting members of the New Democracy and PASOK parties to send a letter to the EU renouncing their austerity pledge, and in the meantime Germany is seeming to say they are open to the idea of Greece making an exit from the euro zone.

We're going to have to hold tight for a little while and wait for the situation to settle, we're going to hold off of a new idea this morning.


Comments
No. Europe will never regain its prominence in the world. They once had resources and a lead in education. Now they have nothing left to work with, and no will to work toward greatness.
Germany may be the exception. They still have a culture of excellence, and are still holding up a little against the liberal onslaught which attacks every standard of behavior required to maintain a society.
The most likely outcome in Europe is a return to the new Spanish Inquisition mentality until the return of Jesus. Many decades ago, Islam targetted European wealth for assumption into their plan to subjugate the world. They have infiltrated most of the continent. As the countries fall economically, Islam will take over with iron-fisted fascism, enforcing their will by use of military might and by being the only hope of being fed. Islam will be able to do this because they hold to personal financial management, as well as believing that they are morally right when they circumvent paying taxes in their businesses. They also use cultural bias to their advantage, spending their money and hiring their workers within the Islamic community while selling their wares and labor to everyone. When the takeover occurs, first other religions will be tolerated, then restricted, then punished, and finally enslaved or killed. If you do jot believe this, then you have not studied Africa.
What is scary is this pattern has been repeated through history and our politicians don't see it (except in France, but they too will fall due to economics). The Bible warns of the consequences of being a debtor. The Marxist mantra demands making your enemies into your financial debtors. Every great social work recognizes this stratagem, but it still works because the "leaders" who fall pray to economic enslavement always believe they are the exception and can make socialism work when it has never succeeded in the history of the world.

Bob G on 5/9/2012 9:02:14 AM
Europe's train wreck is not to be stopped. They are headed for incalulable debt. Incalculable because no one will be able to figure out how all the new indivdual currencies really work. Hopefully their final socialism will be a further warning and instructive to America. If our election looks like France's we will have moved another nano-inch toward our founders' worst nightmare...the breakdown of law/order and our constitutional civil liberties with the unimaginable, possible solution of our own military restoring order and establishing a new government. Then, as the kids say, "game over".

William Remington on 5/9/2012 10:22:48 AM
Europe is fatally flawed with a class system which is so engrained into its social fabric that it cannot be purged. Add to that the influx of Islamic social rules and you have re-established tribal societies. The euro and EU is becoming irrelevant.

z on 5/9/2012 10:25:55 AM
As a former German myself, I can honestly say that I have never seen such a accurate, short history of Germany..

I was in their Krankenkasse, German Obamacare and it was a disaster including 4 to a room in the hospital.

Hitler was the direct result of the Treaty of Versailles. He promised them everything especially their pride and they went for it. Bravo, this is the best thing you have written yet....

thomas Wayne on 5/9/2012 10:32:15 AM
I think the question should be "Can AMERICA ever regain its former glory or has the welfare mentality doomed it to serfdom?" The answer. Not if we re-elect Obama.

Bill Bloodworth on 5/9/2012 10:40:29 AM
It sounds like in Europe, the 1% are the Germans and the 99% are the rest, at least in occupier terms. I am reminded of what used to be a popular saying: when the going gets tough, the tough get going. It is still true, here and in Europe, but the number of those who adhere to it and are tough is shrinking rapidly. Another one my parents had was they'll get their come uppance one day. I beleive those who don't toughen up and get going will get their come uppance. Maybe the so called 1% can't just go on strike a la Atlas Shrugged, but even if we took 75% of their wealth a la France, it just isn't enough for all those anything but tough 99 percenters.

Fran Touchette on 5/9/2012 10:53:19 AM
Don't know whether EU is doomed, but will be a long road. Europeans don't want to sacrifice, or work for that matter. They have always favored socialism, so now they're just digging the hole deeper.

Richard Foust on 5/9/2012 11:58:03 AM
Germany is the key. If Germany goes, Europe goes. If Germany stands fast and the rest crumble around them, the EU goes. Who knows, maybe they fight the Franco-Prussian War all over again.

Dick Kantenberger on 5/9/2012 1:17:07 PM
The Euro will seize to exist. It will actually help to save Europe. Italy which I'm most familiar with wants the lira back. The exchange rate was always favorable for Americans and the tourist industry thrived. The one size fits all Euro was a bad idea from the start.

Lou Amelia on 5/9/2012 2:06:20 PM
Compromise for the common benefit is one thing. Abrogating the ability to define oneself invites enslavement.

Patricia Flynn on 5/9/2012 3:48:59 PM
 

Log In To Add Your Comment


Home | Products & Services | Education | In The Media | Help | About Us |
Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use |
All Rights Reserved.

 

×